Religious freedom is a foundational value — enshrined in the First Amendment, invoked in social movements from abolition to civil rights, and essential to human dignity.
The right to believe, worship, and live according to one’s faith — or to live free from religion — is vital in any pluralistic society.
But in 2025, religious freedom is being weaponized — twisted from a shield protecting personal conscience into a sword wielded against the rights of others.
Across the United States, courts, legislatures, and political movements are invoking “religious liberty” to justify discrimination against LGBTQ+ people, deny healthcare access, erode civil rights protections, and impose sectarian beliefs onto public life.
This is not freedom.
This is theocratic encroachment disguised as constitutional principle.
When “religious freedom” becomes a tool for subjugation rather than sanctuary, it ceases to be a right worth defending. It becomes oppression by another name.
Religious Freedom: What It Was Meant to Be
The architects of American democracy — flawed though they were — understood that religious freedom was essential to a just society.
The First Amendment states:
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
Two core principles emerge:
1. Free Exercise: Individuals have the right to practice their religion without government interference.
2. Establishment Clause: The government must remain neutral in matters of religion — neither promoting nor inhibiting any faith.
Together, these clauses were intended to create a delicate balance:
Protect private belief, prevent public imposition.
Faith was to be personal, not political.
Communal, not compulsory.
But in recent decades — especially accelerated in the Trump-Musk era — religious freedom has been increasingly reinterpreted not as a right to personal conscience, but as a right to control others.
How Religious Freedom Is Being Weaponized Today
1. Denial of Services Based on Religious Beliefs
Businesses and individuals now routinely claim religious exemptions to deny goods, services, or care to LGBTQ+ people, women, and others.
Examples include:
• Bakeries refusing to make wedding cakes for same-sex couples.
• Medical providers denying gender-affirming care to transgender patients.
• Employers refusing to cover contraception in health insurance plans.
Under the guise of “religious freedom,” marginalized people are pushed to the margins — again.
Freedom of belief has been mutated into freedom to discriminate.
2. Religious Exemptions from Non-Discrimination Laws
In some states, so-called Religious Freedom Restoration Acts (RFRAs) allow individuals and businesses to opt out of civil rights protections by citing religious beliefs.
This creates a two-tiered system:
• One set of rules for those deemed worthy of protection.
• Another for those deemed acceptable to harm.
Civil rights cannot be conditional.
Equality under the law must mean equality for everyone, not just for those who meet a religious litmus test.
3. Politicization of Public Schools
Efforts to inject Christian nationalist ideology into public education have escalated, including:
• Reintroducing mandatory school prayer.
• Mandating religious curricula under the guise of “patriotic education.”
• Banning LGBTQ+ books, lessons, and student organizations under claims of “religious values.”
Public schools are not churches.
Students of all faiths — or no faith — deserve an education free from religious coercion.
4. Erosion of Reproductive Rights
Religious beliefs about when life begins are now being enshrined into state laws that ban abortion, restrict contraception, and criminalize miscarriage management.
This violates the fundamental principle that no religious belief should dictate public policy in a pluralistic democracy.
The right to bodily autonomy cannot hinge on someone else’s theology.
The Real Victims of Weaponized Religious Freedom
It is important to name who suffers when religious liberty is distorted:
• LGBTQ+ people denied service, healthcare, dignity.
• Women denied reproductive care and autonomy.
• Religious minorities — Muslims, Jews, Sikhs, Hindus, atheists — marginalized by the dominance of Christian nationalist politics.
• Disabled people denied equitable education and care under religious exemptions.
• Youth trapped in coercive environments where conformity is demanded over critical thought.
Weaponized religion does not create freedom.
It creates hierarchies — who deserves rights, and who does not.
The Hypocrisy of “Selective” Religious Freedom
A critical point often missed in mainstream coverage:
Not all religions are treated equally.
Christian nationalist interpretations dominate religious freedom litigation and legislation — while non-Christian faiths often find themselves excluded or outright targeted.
• Muslim Americans face surveillance and discrimination.
• Jewish Americans are targeted by antisemitic rhetoric and attacks, even by politicians claiming to defend “Judeo-Christian values.”
• Indigenous spiritual practices are still marginalized and criminalized in various contexts.
Religious freedom, if it were applied equitably, would protect all faiths — not just the majority’s.
When it only shields one tradition, it is not freedom.
It is religious supremacy.
The Ethical Crisis: Whose Rights Matter?
The distortion of religious freedom reveals a deeper ethical crisis:
Do we believe rights belong to everyone — or only to those in power?
The right to believe privately must never override another person’s right to exist publicly without discrimination.
Your religious convictions may inform your personal choices.
They do not entitle you to control someone else’s life.
Belief is private.
Rights are public.
And in a free society, no one’s theology should dictate another’s humanity.
What True Religious Freedom Looks Like
If we reclaim religious freedom’s true meaning, it must involve:
• Protection for individual conscience without imposing it onto others.
• Safeguards for religious minorities, not just the Christian majority.
• Secular public spaces where all students, patients, and citizens are respected equally.
• Firm non-discrimination standards that no religious belief can override.
• Recognition that freedom of religion also includes freedom from religion.
True religious freedom uplifts everyone — because it ensures no one’s rights hinge on someone else’s belief system.
Final Reflections: Faith Must Never Be a Weapon
Faith can be beautiful. It can nourish communities, inspire justice movements, offer solace in despair.
But faith, when weaponized, becomes tyranny.
We must not allow “religious freedom” to become a euphemism for legalizing harm.
We must resist every attempt to turn conscience into coercion, difference into danger, belief into brutality.
The future of real freedom — of democracy itself — depends on our ability to recognize this distinction and defend it fiercely.
In a just society:
• Your faith is yours to cherish.
• My body, my identity, my autonomy remain mine to protect.
• Our shared public life remains open, free, and respectful of all.
Because true religious freedom does not demand dominance.
It demands dignity.
And dignity belongs to all of us — without exception.
Gemma Ortwerth 
Leave a comment